Chicken or Beef Bone Broth When Sick: What’s Better?

Whether you’re battling a stubborn cold, recovering from the flu, or simply feeling run down, the age-old remedy of sipping warm bone broth remains a trusted staple in many households. But when it comes to choosing between chicken and beef bone broth, the decision isn’t always clear-cut. Each offers unique benefits, from gentle digestibility to robust mineral content, making it essential to know which broth best matches your needs when you’re under the weather.

What Is Chicken Bone Broth?

Chicken bone broth is a nutrient-rich liquid made by simmering chicken bones—often with a mix of connective tissue, cartilage, and sometimes meat—alongside vegetables, herbs, and spices for several hours. This slow cooking process extracts valuable minerals, collagen, amino acids, and gelatin from the bones, resulting in a flavorful, nourishing broth. Traditionally used as both a culinary base and a healing remedy, chicken bone broth is prized for its light, easily digestible nature and its potential to support immune health, soothe the digestive tract, and provide gentle hydration when you’re feeling unwell.

What Is Beef Bone Broth?

Beef bone broth is a hearty, mineral-rich liquid created by simmering beef bones—often including marrow, joints, and connective tissue—along with vegetables, herbs, and spices for an extended period, typically 12 to 24 hours. This slow extraction process draws out a wealth of nutrients such as collagen, gelatin, amino acids, and essential minerals like calcium, magnesium, and phosphorus. The result is a robust, deeply flavored broth that is celebrated for its ability to support joint health, replenish minerals, and provide sustained nourishment, making it a popular choice for those seeking a more substantial and restorative remedy when feeling sick or run down.

Chicken or Beef Bone Broth When Sick: What’s Better?

Chicken Bone Broth: Best for Gentle Healing

• Easier to Digest: Chicken bone broth is lighter and gentler on the stomach, making it ideal for those with nausea, digestive upset, or reduced appetite.
• Soothes Sore Throats: Its mild flavor and warmth can help ease sore throats and provide comfort when you’re congested.
• Quick Energy: The amino acids and electrolytes in chicken broth are quickly absorbed, offering fast hydration and energy during illness.
• Traditional Remedy: Long used in home remedies for colds and flu, chicken broth is often recommended for children, the elderly, or anyone needing a gentle, nourishing option.

Beef Bone Broth: Best for Deep Nourishment

• Richer in Minerals: Beef bone broth typically contains higher levels of minerals like calcium, magnesium, and phosphorus, which support recovery and overall health.
• Supports Joint and Tissue Repair: The collagen and gelatin from beef bones are especially beneficial for joint health and tissue repair, which can be helpful during recovery.
• More Satisfying: Its robust flavor and denser nutrient profile make beef broth a good choice for those with bigger appetites or needing more substantial nourishment.
• Longer-Lasting Energy: The deeper, richer nutrients in beef broth can provide longer-lasting energy and satiety, supporting strength during prolonged illness.

How Does Beef Bone Broth Differ In Nutrients From Chicken Broth?

Beef bone broth and chicken bone broth differ notably in their nutrient profiles due to the types of bones and connective tissues used. Beef bone broth is generally richer in minerals such as calcium, magnesium, and phosphorus, thanks to the dense, marrow-filled beef bones. It also tends to have higher levels of collagen and gelatin, which support joint and tissue health. In contrast, chicken bone broth is typically lighter, with a higher concentration of easily digestible amino acids like glycine and proline, and it often contains more immune-supportive compounds extracted from the cartilage and skin. While both broths provide valuable nutrients, beef bone broth offers deeper mineral content and a heartier nutritional profile, whereas chicken bone broth excels in gentle, restorative nourishment and digestibility.

Does One Broth Hydrate Better Than The Other?

Both chicken and beef bone broths are excellent sources of hydration, especially when you’re sick, as they provide fluids along with electrolytes like sodium and potassium that help maintain fluid balance in the body. However, chicken bone broth is often considered slightly better for hydration because it is lighter, easier to sip in larger amounts, and typically contains a higher concentration of easily absorbed electrolytes. Its gentle nature makes it more appealing when you have a reduced appetite or sensitive stomach, allowing you to drink more and stay hydrated. While beef bone broth also hydrates well, its richer flavor and denser texture may make it less suitable for consuming in large quantities when you’re feeling unwell.

Are There Situations Where Mixing Or Alternating Both Makes Sense?

Yes, there are situations where mixing or alternating both chicken and beef bone broths can be especially beneficial. Combining the two allows you to enjoy the unique advantages of each: the gentle, easily digestible qualities of chicken broth and the mineral-rich, deeply nourishing properties of beef broth. Alternating between them can help prevent flavor fatigue, provide a broader spectrum of nutrients, and support different stages of recovery—using chicken broth for hydration and soothing comfort when symptoms are acute, and beef broth for deeper nourishment and strength as you regain your appetite. This balanced approach ensures you’re covering a wider range of nutritional needs and maximizing the healing potential of both broths during illness.

Why Chicken or Beef Bone Broth When Sick Is a Great Choice

Common Mistakes To Avoid When Taking Chicken or Beef Bone Broth When Sick

• Choosing Store-Bought Broths With Additives: Many commercial broths contain preservatives, excess sodium, or artificial flavors that can undermine the health benefits; always opt for high-quality, minimally processed options or make your own at home.
• Not Simmering Long Enough: Short cooking times may not extract the full range of nutrients, collagen, and minerals from the bones—aim for at least 8–24 hours of simmering for maximum benefit.
• Skipping the Vinegar: Adding a splash of vinegar helps draw minerals and gelatin from the bones, enhancing the nutritional value of your broth.
• Ignoring Portion Size: Drinking too much at once, especially beef broth, can overwhelm sensitive stomachs; start with small servings and increase gradually as tolerated.
• Neglecting to Skim Fat and Impurities: Failing to skim off excess fat and foam during cooking can result in a greasy texture and less appealing flavor, making the broth harder to digest when you’re unwell.

Conclusion

Both chicken and beef bone broths offer powerful, natural support when you’re feeling under the weather, each bringing unique strengths to your recovery. Chicken bone broth shines for its gentle, easily digestible qualities and soothing hydration, making it ideal for acute illness or sensitive stomachs. Beef bone broth, on the other hand, provides deeper nourishment with its rich mineral content and robust flavor, supporting strength and tissue repair as you regain your health. Whether you choose one, alternate between both, or even mix them, incorporating bone broth into your routine can help you recover faster, stay hydrated, and nourish your body in a wholesome, time-honored way.

Final Thoughts

Curious about the best way to support your wellness and beauty while recovering from illness or boosting your immunity? Check out Dr. Kellyann’s best sellers for a range of keto-friendly chicken, beef, and french onion bone broths that nourish from within. For daily anti-aging support, try Collagen Peptides, or satisfy your cravings with chocolate and vanilla shakes from Dr. Kellyann’s collection. Make your self-care routine both delicious and effective with the trusted products from Dr. Kellyann’s.

Sources

1. https://steakschool.com/learn/everything-you-need-to-know-about-beef-bone-broth/
2. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/bone-broth
3. https://thewell.northwell.edu/healthy-living-fitness/benefits-of-bone-broth