Coconut Key Lime Pie Popsicles

These Coconut Key Lime Pie Popsicles are so good, you’ll want to keep a stash in the freezer for the whole summer! Creamy coconut, zesty lime, sweet white chocolate, and crunchy vanilla wafers give you all the flavors you love about this popular pie, but as a refreshing frozen treat.

Once I made our Watermelon Wine Freeze Pops and Meal-Prep Smoothie Popsicles, I realized just how EASY it was to make your own. And such a fun summer activity to involve the kiddos with 🥰🥰

With this coconut key lime popsicle recipe, there’s no more buying expensive, sugary popsicles from the store! You can make your own with all-natural ingredients, some popsicle molds, a good mix here and there, and a simple assembly.

Then, just pop them (no pun intended 😂) into the freezer and put your patient hat on. The only hard part is waiting for them to freeze.

Coconut Key Lime Pie Popsicles – What You Need

• Cans coconut cream: The base for these key lime popsicles, coconut cream is essential for that creamy, tropical taste.
• Agave: The PERFECT natural sweetener for this recipe. It has a mild honey flavor and is less likely to crystallize in the freezer than sugar.
• Lime: We used lime juice and lime zest to give these popsicles that amazing key lime flavor!
• White chocolate chips: White chocolate tastes fantastic with the lime flavor of these coconut lime popsicles! It also makes them more sweet and indulgent.
• Coconut oil: Coconut oil helps the white chocolate stay melty and gives these popsicles a nice, smooth texture.
• Nilla wafers: We crumble these up to mimic a pie crust in the popsicle!
• Popsicle molds: You’ll need some type of popsicle mold for these tasty treats.

Other Tasty Topping Ideas

Swap the white chocolate with dark chocolate or even coconut shavings for a different flavor and texture.

You can also use other crumbled cookies or graham crackers for the crust instead of Nilla wafers. Oreo cookies or Biscoff cookies are two delicious options to try!

Love all things key lime pie?

Try our Easy Coconut Key Lime Pie Bars! The flaky crust is made with almond flour, shredded coconut, and honey, and the key lime pie filling is ultra moist and decadent. You’ll be obsessed!

How to Store Coconut Key Lime Pie Popsicles

If you have leftover popsicles, store them in an airtight container or plastic bag in the freezer. They should last for up to 2 weeks.